Scorecard

This is not a scoreboard of formal recommendations. Most of what these sources say is more conditional than "buy" or "sell" — an entry price they'd want first, a name they're steering clear of, a thesis they hold with caveats. We record the direction they leaned and link straight back to the source so you can hear it in their own words. Treat the columns as a starting point for your own research, not a verdict on anyone.

Calls have no end date. Each one is measured from the day it was made to the most recent close — nobody is assumed to have sold. That flatters a call whose thesis has since broken and penalises one that worked and then faded, so a long-running row says less than a recent one.

Everything is measured against the S&P 500 over the identical window. That is what makes a call from May comparable with one from last week, without annualising anything. A sell call counts as right when the name lagged the index — a stock that fell less than the market was not a good sell.

Entry is the first close on or after the day of the call — the price you could actually have paid. Repeat calls on the same name count separately. A source's past hit rate says nothing reliable about their next call.